Rated Battle Ground 6/10
A week ago when I finished and reviewed the previous book, "Peace Talks" (16), I noted the exceptionally unusual development(?) that for once Harry had spent the entire book actually exhausting every possible avenue of diplomacy and non-confrontation. Of course, the book left the reader on a "to be continued" note and this book immediately picks up there. Soon after I started this book, I came across an interview of Butcher in which he mentions that the two books came out back-to-back because they started out as a single book. Then as time went on and it became tome-like, he/his editor(s) decided to split it into two. And now it makes sense as to why "Peace Talks" was all diplomacy and, now that I've finished this book obviously by the title it was all battle.<br/><br/>So about that... As others have said in a few reviews I read when I was getting to the back end of the book, I really don't think it was a good move to split the story into two books. I think it was a bad decision of editing. Even if the last book had become 600pp long, 300pp of skirmish after skirmish, setting up a returning character in each one, just became repetitive and a bit tedious. I certainly skimmed a good 100 pages of the back half mainly making note of which characters showed up and what if anything unusual happened with each. Other than Harry, I'd say of allll the characters who got their spotlight, five of them I felt were of the most consequence by the end. By the time I got to the last one, with a twist, I mostly just wanted to get to the end. It's not a terrible book, but it's was definitely a misstep in what I expect from a Dresden Files book.<br/><br/>One final thought: Unsurprisingly, LOTR is one of Butcher's favorite and influencing books. Remember Archangel Uriel giving Dresden a copy of "The Two Towers" in "Small Favor" (10)? It seems that we're up to "The Two Towers" with this endless battle.<br/><br/>And now here's where I put all the spoilers, so if you've not read this book, now's the time to stop reading or to not click this <spoiler>.<br/><br/>So yeah. All things had been pointing towards Murphy's death for a couple of books now. I was really hoping she wasn't getting off'd, but figured it was happening. I was still annoyed when it happened and had to put the book down for a short while before continuing the slog of endless skirmishes. On the other hand, as I and many others expected, she'll probably become a valkyrie. It would be the way to get around the whole immortal-mortal finite relationship problem, but there's the detail Gard said that everyone would have to forget who she was before the All-Father brings her back. So, how will everyone have their memory of her erased? That's what I'm wondering. A favor from Mab, Molly, or The Leanansidhe since at least 2 of them have pulled off that trick before? However, if it turns out she's really gone for good because Butcher decided to fridge her, what a garbage way to go. I mean, it's a garbage way to go either way, but the whole "she died killing a Jotun" just isn't true! She was killed by some asshat, Rudolph, who'd been ruining her life since nearly the beginning of the series! AFTER killing the Jotun.<br/><br/>As for the other 4, I keep rooting for the ever greater Toot-Toot! Now I'm kind of meh on the whole turning of Molly into the Winter Lady. I still roll my eyes at the whole Butters as a Knight with a light saber Sword. And finally, the big reveal at the end of Marcone getting his neck snapped by Ethniu and thrown on the ground only for the the head to rotate back and the second pair of eyes appearing above Marcone's, the eyes of Denarian Thorned Namshiel. Yep, he's been hiding out in Marcone since "Small Favor" (10). Ugh! I got so excited that Marcone's neck had been snapped! Only for this to happen! I've been wanting him gone since many books back. The good news is I can't wait for Mab to find out Marcone is colluding with Namshiel. She's going to rip him to shreds for Namshiel's attack on Arctis Tor back in "Small Favor"!<br/><br/>Now about Harry. "Excommunicated" by the White Council because he's become too powerful/scary. Also, he made a deal with Listens-To-Wind about having a conversation over what the hell is going on with the whole Starborn thing. Interestingly, as is left at the end once Ethniu the Last Titan is locked up in Demonreach, Mab decides to marry him off to Lara Raith - in a year's time. Mab and the White (Grey?) Council colluding? Or are they both manuevering to control Harry using the same star chart or whatever the hell? Honestly, the whole Starborn thing has dragged on long enough. Butcher needs to drop the knowledge already! How is this going to go on for another NINE books?? / rant</spoiler>