Matty zweifelt an den Absichten des Mannes, der behauptet, Alfies Vater zu sein. Währenddessen übernimmt die Kanzlei einen Brandstiftungsfall und Olympia versucht, Julian zu schützen.

Brilliant attorney Madeline Matlock rejoins the work force at a prestigious law firm where she uses her cleverness tactics to win cases. Matty is assigned to Olympia, an attorney with a thirst for justice. Olympia's ex-husband, Julian, the son of the head of the firm, is intrigued by Matty and her skills. Matty works alongside the firm's younger associates – Billy and Sarah.